What happened to MrBtongue? A Tasteful, Understated, Nerdrage interview

“MrBtongue” is a video mashup creator – you may have seen his series on YouTube, titled “Tasteful, Understated Nerdrage”.

The TUN videos detail his opinions of not only specific video games (it all started with Mass Effect 3, and continues with Dragon Age, Skyrim and others), but also includes his views on the state of the gaming industry, analysis of games’ thematic strengths and weaknesses (including multiple cram courses on what makes good storytelling), and recommendations for making games better.

That last one is big – it’s easy to complain, but how often do you see a “nerdrage” video with intelligent solutions to a problem?

The short summary of all of the above: MrBtongue has released videos that are entertaining, relevant and intelligent, of interest to geeks everywhere.

An even shorter summary is from YouTuber pauliewasson: “MrBtongue is the last, best hope for videogame journalism.”

The below is an interview with MrBtongue, who has graciously donated his time to answer a few questions.

Andy: MrBtongue, thanks for your time today! Let’s start with the big one: What’s happening with you? Some rumors are that Electronic Arts has hired you away to oversee game design in a secluded basement room. Or they’ve gone the other direction, and have hired ninjas to silence you permanently. Are you still alive? Does TUN have a future?

MrBtongue: I always assume there are ninjas nearby at all times, but so far they haven’t done me any harm, nor have I been hired by EA. What really happened is that I had to study for some big tests (the CPA exam) and took a break from the videos to do that. Unfortunately I left a bit abruptly and without much explanation, and I’m sorry for everyone who was left wondering.

I do have plans for more videos – I hope to have one in the next couple of weeks, though experience has taught me not to commit to too much of a schedule, as I do get busy with other things. Just today the trailer for CD Projekt’s Cyberpunk game came out, and that’s the excuse I need to finish up the cyberpunk video.

Andy: Part of TUN is insight and education. You’ve shown in great detail what makes a good game. You’ve taught what “Gesamtkunstwerk” means. Being able to apply such knowledge means more than restating Wikipedia. How did you get to this point? Can you give more detail on your background?

MrBtongue: Spend a decade or so of your life overeducated, underemployed, and with access to the internet, and you’ll develop useless knowledge on a wide range of subjects. In college I studied literature and music, and thought about going into graduate school for literature (though I didn’t). Now I just read a lot (including wikipedia) and learn where I can.

Andy: You have a handle on the state of the video gaming industry. A year ago, one of your videos presents the idea that smaller game companies can and should be able to compete against the massive game publishers like EA, particularly in areas of development costs and creative control. Do you still see this change happening? Where do you see the industry in the future?

MrBtongue: I do think the momentum is going to switch towards smaller developers, though I suspect it’s going to happen frustratingly slowly. The main advantage of the EA/Activision approach was their ability to raise lots of capital, but their financial performance hasn’t necessarily justified the amount they’ve raised, and we’ve already seen their pace of acquisitions and growth slow down.

I should note though that while I know my way around a spreadsheet, I’m not a financial analyst or anything, and not immune to wishful thinking either. But I do think that smaller studios are going to take a more leading role in the future.

Andy: You know what makes a good story and how that ties in with what makes a good video game. Do you have interest in writing or story design work (in or outside of gaming)?

MrBtongue: I do – but of course jobs aren’t easy to come by these days, and especially jobs in gaming.

Andy: Several commenters have expressed interest in giving you money to ensure more quality content. Any thoughts on monetizing the TUN videos?

MrBtongue: I have looked into monetizing them, but the first couple avenues I looked into I didn’t go with for various reasons. Then the whole thing went on backburner with the videos themselves. I’ll probably start looking into that again once I get back into the swing of making them regularly. I’ve been complaining about things so long for free that it’s strange to think of making money from it.

Andy: What do you do when you’re not expressing nerdrage?

MrBtongue: I work at a nonprofit in San Diego part-time, I’m a student part-time, and teach saxophone. I play games too, of course, generally RPG and strategy.

Andy: Anything not covered here you’d like to mention? Any other projects you’re working on?

MrBtongue: Just my next video, ETA two weeks maybe? I have a backlog of subjects – after cyberpunk is MMOs, and then violence in video games. I also have some plans for shorter segments, which are not reviews of entire games but detailed pieces on very small bits of them. Difficult to explain.

Andy: Pretend that EA’s ninjas have marooned you on a desert island. There’s a Kickstarter campaign to save you, but the project won’t close for another couple weeks. You have an Alienware gaming rig, crippled to allow an install of only one game. You have plenty of food and liquids. It’s 2013. What game would you play while you waited for rescue?

MrBtongue: Yeeeeesh that’s hard. Right now I’m playing the Baldur’s Gate Enhanced Edition and Far Cry 3, which are both good, but I think if I absolutely had to choose only one at the moment it’d be Skyrim. Not necessarily because it’s the best (though it’s very good), but because it’s the biggest and would vacuum up the most time.

Andy: Thanks for your responses!


  1. NIck says:

    This is ABSOLUTELY FANTASTIC. MrBtongue is one of my favorite people on the internet and I’ve missed him terribly. I’m really glad to hear that he’s coming back. He’s really inspired me in a lot of ways, which probably sounds dumb, but there’s just something inspiring about seeing someone so intelligently discuss something that you really care about. It makes you feel a lot more valid. Suddenly, something you thought nobody really cared about is being intelligently and extensively discussed in front of you, by someone who shares your opinions and likes the same things you do. That really means a lot to me, more than you’d think. Anyway, I’m glad to hear he’s going to make more videos, and I really can’t wait.

    • HDaudioCoYotE says:

      you spoke my mind !
      great to hear he’s coming back. That makes developing games much more thought-out and fun. I’ve been listening to his videos so many times!
      And it’s really the way he summarise and analyses the things what we care about in gaming! As developers and long time gamers alike.
      He pushed my thoughts in game-developement (both my paycheck-job and my oprivate-projects) back on the “right” path :D
      Thanks MrB ! 
      All the best from Germany!

  2. Andy Kaiser says:

    Thanks, Nick. I feel the same way.

  3. goose2989 says:

    I’m just glad to hear that Mr. Case isn’t dead

  4. Nobody says:

    Very cool to hear he’s still around – and going to make more videos, even! Great interview.

  5. teegal says:

    So he’ll be back? This is great news! I’m looking forward to finally seeing him rise from the dead again. Welcome back, MrBtongue!

  6. CureLight says:

    Yes! I’m excited!

  7. Grafknar says:

    Thanks to MrBtongue for all his hard work in those vids; if he wanted to monetize them, he could have a good income stream.  Word of mouth marketing would make it a slam dunk.

    Regardless, MrBtongue, your fans support you in any endeavor.  Best of luck with the CPA exam; tear it up no matter what you do!


  8. Toni Pop says:

    Oh god, he’s back. I think I’m gonna cry.

  9. Dean says:

    He’s alive! 

  10. luke says:

    Mr. Btongues back! yes!!!! idk if you know this but i showed my my lit teacher your elder scrolls vid and showed his whole classes, im gunna push to have all my schools lit teachers show your videos that it might give the publicity you deserve and show they world a think or two about story telling! god i could cry right now :’)

  11. chris says:

    THANK GOD he`s still alive!! :D

    I was so worried that youtube had lost its most intelligent game reviewer. Glad to know i was wrong.

  12. DocTorchwood says:

    OH GOD YES HE’S BACK YES YES YES. I really hope this is real and that he is truely coming back after all of this time and he finishes his video on Cyperpunk but for some reason I think that this interview is fake but I hope its not.

    • Andy Kaiser says:

      This would be an awful lot of hassle to go through for a fake interview. Regardless of what you think of me, though, I would recommend just being patient. Good things will happen.